How General Contractors Should Pay Themselves

Most contractors pay themselves whatever is left over. A good month, a bigger draw. A slow month, almost nothing. It feels like financial discipline, because you are not taking money the business does not have. But it's actually one of the most expensive habits a contractor can have, and it has nothing to do with the amount.

The structure of how you pay yourself matters as much as how much. Get it wrong and you're leaving money on the table for the IRS, creating cash flow problems you can't diagnose, and making it nearly impossible to know if your business is actually profitable.

The three ways contractors pay themselves

There are essentially three structures, and which one is right depends on your entity type and your income level.

Owner draws (sole proprietors and single-member LLCs)

If you're operating as a sole proprietor or a single-member LLC taxed as a disregarded entity, owner draws are how you get money out. You take cash from the business account and record it as a draw against owner's equity. It's simple, flexible, and completely normal.

The tax implication: all net profit flows to your personal return as self-employment income, whether you drew it or not. So the draw itself is not a taxable event. You are taxed on what the business earns, not what you take. This matters for cash flow planning. If your business earns $200K but you only drew $120K, you are still taxed on the full $200K of net profit, not the $120K you took.

W-2 salary (S-corps)

If you've elected S-corp status, the IRS requires you to pay yourself a reasonable salary as a W-2 employee before taking any distributions. The salary is subject to payroll taxes. Distributions above the salary are not. This is the primary tax advantage of the S-corp structure. You reduce the portion of your income subject to self-employment tax.

The practical complexity: you need payroll set up, quarterly deposits, and a salary that the IRS would consider reasonable for your role and industry. Too low a salary invites scrutiny. Whether and when the S-corp structure makes sense for you is a question for your CPA, not a blog post.

Mixed draws and distributions (partnerships, multi-member LLCs)

If you have partners or co-owners, the structure gets more complex. Guaranteed payments, profit distributions, and equity splits all interact. This is a conversation for your CPA, not a blog post.

The real problem: draws that look like expenses

The most common mistake in contractor finances is not the structure. It's the bookkeeping. Owner draws recorded as expenses. Personal purchases run through the business account and categorized as job costs or supplies. Loan repayments mixed with operating costs.

When that happens, your P&L is wrong. Your gross margin looks worse than it is. Your net income is understated. And when you try to figure out whether a job was profitable, the numbers don't add up because the owner's compensation is hidden inside the cost structure.

Clean books separate owner compensation from operating costs. Draws go to equity, not expenses. That's the foundation everything else depends on.

How much should you pay yourself?

This is the question most contractors actually want answered, and it's the hardest one to give a general answer to. But here's a useful framework.

Think about your compensation in two layers. First, what would you pay someone else to do your job in the field? If you're running crews, managing jobs, and doing estimating, that work has a market rate. That's your floor. Your business should be able to support that compensation before you consider it healthy.

Second, what return are you getting as an owner on top of that? The profit the business generates above your market-rate compensation is your return on the risk and capital you've put in. If you can't separate these two numbers, you can't tell if your business is actually building value or just paying you a wage.

The cash flow trap

The most common version of the "profitable but broke" problem in contractor businesses involves owner draws. The business earns money, the owner draws it out, and then a large materials invoice or equipment payment hits and there's nothing left.

The fix is a draw discipline: decide in advance what percentage of monthly net profit you'll take as a draw, and hold the rest as a cash buffer. Seasonal businesses especially need a reserve through slow months. A draw policy makes this automatic instead of reactive.

Your bookkeeper can show you the draws. A finance pro reading the same books can tell you whether the timing and amount of those draws is sustainable given your cash cycle, job backlog, and seasonal pattern.

What clean compensation structure enables

When your owner draws are properly structured and recorded, a few things become possible that aren't possible otherwise.

You can see your actual gross margin by job type. You can benchmark your labor cost percentage against industry norms. You can tell whether your business generates enough profit to support your lifestyle without undercapitalizing the company. And when you eventually want to sell the business, or bring in a partner, or apply for a line of credit, you'll have financials that actually reflect the business.

None of that requires a complicated structure. It just requires that the draws come out of the right place in the books, on a consistent basis, with a clear policy behind them.

Your CPA handles the tax structure. BooksSteady handles the monthly clarity. If you can't read your own P&L clearly, you can't make good decisions about compensation or anything else.

Paying yourself correctly isn't a one-time decision. It's something to revisit at least once a year, ideally more often. Your business changes. The tax code changes. Your personal financial situation changes. The structure that made sense when you started may not be the right one for where you are today.

← Back to all posts